PRACTICE WITH JOY RESEARCH

Can Nurse Practitioners
Save Primary Care?

“I'm doing all of this work and I'm not getting reimbursed... so why am I doing this?”

— Nurse practitioner, 7 years in practice
0
conversations
0
states
0+
specialties

What they told us about the future of independent practice

We spoke with nurse practitioners considering practice ownership — not through surveys, but in real one-on-one conversations. What they told us challenges the conventional wisdom about who wants to go independent and why.

THE CONTEXT

America is running out of primary care.

77M+ Americans in primary care shortage areas HRSA, 2025
199 Rural counties with zero physicians Commonwealth Fund, 2025
48,000 Projected primary care physician shortage by 2034 AAMC, 2021

Two in five active physicians will reach retirement age within the next decade (AAMC, 2024). Medical students are choosing specialty care over family medicine. The pipeline is drying up.

But there's a workforce that could fill the gap.

The United States has over 461,000 licensed nurse practitioners — with projected employment growth of 35-40% over the next decade, making NPs the fastest-growing role in healthcare (BLS, 2024). Eighty-seven percent are trained in primary care. In 27 states plus the District of Columbia, they can diagnose, prescribe, and manage patients independently — up from just 22 states before the pandemic. (AANP, 2026; AANP, 2020)

The problem: they're burning out.

70% of NPs report burnout or depression Nurse.org, 2024
58% cite excessive bureaucratic tasks Medscape, 2024
$86-120K cost per NP turnover episode SullivanCotter / Nursing Outlook, 2024

The people most equipped to solve the primary care crisis are themselves in crisis. They're leaving positions at 10–20% per year (Nursing Outlook, 2024) — not because they don't love patient care, but because the system around them has become unbearable. As one psychiatric NP working for a county system told us, "I became a nurse practitioner thinking that I could have the independence of providing the care I want to. And right now I just don't feel like I can do it here."

Some are trying to break out. Most can't.

34% of NPs say they want to own a practice (Nurse.org, 2024). For most, it stays an aspiration — the barriers between wanting to and actually doing it remain significant. Meanwhile, independent practices are disappearing: the share of physicians in private practice fell from 60.1% to 42.2% in just twelve years (AMA Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 2024).

NP Workforce 461K+ 35-40% projected growth by 2034 Up from ~270K in 2019 (AANP) AANP, 2025
Independent Practices 42% of physicians in private practice Down from 60% in 2012 AMA Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 2024

More providers than ever. Fewer independent practices than ever. The workforce is growing — the pathway to ownership is not.

OUR RESEARCH

We talked to 160 nurse practitioners about practice ownership.

160 nurse practitioners across 36 states. November 2024 – December 2025. Here's what they told us.

Each dot represents a real conversation — a nurse practitioner who reached out to explore what practice ownership might look like. Together, they form a dataset unlike anything in published NP workforce research: not survey checkboxes, but real dialogue about real decisions. What follows is what we found.

Psych / Mental Health
Primary Care
Multi-specialty
Other
Methodology: Qualitative analysis of 160 inbound consultation calls. Participants self-selected by calling a healthcare practice launch advisory line. Calls averaged 23 minutes. No compensation was offered. Repeat callers (16, 10%) counted once in demographics.
WHO THEY ARE

Not who you'd expect

Demographics of 160 NPs exploring independent practice.

The conventional image of a nurse practitioner starting a practice is a seasoned veteran hanging a shingle after decades of clinical experience. Our data tells a different story.

The 160 NPs we spoke with span 36 states and every major specialty. They come from hospital systems, group practices, insurance companies, academic institutions, and government facilities. Nearly one in five currently works for an insurance company — they've seen the healthcare system from inside the payer machine and decided they'd rather be on the other side of it. Psychiatric and mental health NPs make up the largest single specialty at 28%, followed by primary care at 24%. Sixteen percent plan to offer multiple specialties.

Where they are

36 states represented, FL leads with 25

What they practice

28% psych/mental health — the largest group

Where they work now

Hospital systems and group practices top the list

How they want to practice

54% want hybrid — telehealth + in-person
Percentages exceed 100% — some NPs reported working in multiple settings.

In 27 states plus the District of Columbia, nurse practitioners have full practice authority; in the other 23 states, they must work under a physician collaborator or supervisor. (AANP, 2026) Our dataset splits almost evenly across both — 47% from full-practice states, 53% from restricted — and the top four by call volume (Florida, California, Arizona, Texas) reflect population more than regulation. These NPs know the rules cold. One Florida NP told us she was planning to launch her practice in Washington state instead because at home, "I have to pay for a collaborating physician and all that." Interest in ownership shows up across the country — and so does clear-eyed awareness of what it'll cost.

WHAT'S PUSHING THEM OUT

They're not running away. They're at a crossroads.

The popular narrative is that NPs go independent because they're burned out. It's more complicated than that. While a quarter of NPs we spoke with expressed frustration with their current situation, only 4% cited escaping their employer as their primary motivation. More often, burnout was the backdrop — not the trigger. The most common primary motivations were entrepreneurial ambition (23%) and a desire for autonomy (20%) — or as one family NP put it, "I'm here Monday through Friday, 8 to 5. I don't like that. Someone else is dictating my schedule."

Primary motivation

When we could identify a specific triggering event, the pattern was clear: 68% were life transitions — a relocation, a retirement, a layoff — not workplace frustration. One women's health NP described it simply: "I just moved... I can't commute anymore. So I do telehealth part time and just trying to figure out how to start my own practice."

Based on 37 contacts (24%) with identifiable triggering events

Motivation shifts with experience

Veterans (10+ yrs) 32% Autonomy
Early Career (2-5 yrs) 23% Entrepreneurial
New Grads (<2 yrs) 25% Autonomy

Veterans want control. Early-career NPs want to build. New grads are split.

n=82, 51% of contacts classified

This isn't a solo decision

52%

mentioned a partner, spouse, or co-founder in their decision. 36 mentioned a spouse specifically. 6 calls were the non-NP partner — doing the research on behalf of the clinician.

WHAT THEY WANT TO BUILD

Not your grandfather's family practice

The practices these NPs envision look nothing like the traditional family medicine clinic. When asked about their practice model, 54% described a hybrid approach — combining telehealth with in-person care. Only 9% want a purely brick-and-mortar practice. Five percent are planning mobile practices, bringing care directly to patients' homes.

This hybrid preference has significant infrastructure implications. It means multi-state licensing, dual credentialing tracks, and technology platforms that support both virtual and physical encounters. The infrastructure gap isn't just about getting credentialed — it's about supporting a practice model that didn't exist a decade ago.

54%

want hybrid — telehealth plus in-person

The services these NPs plan to offer reveal an even more dramatic shift.

The GLP-1 gold rush is reshaping practice plans

24%

mentioned weight loss or GLP-1 services

36%

of those are primary care NPs pivoting to weight management

This isn't just opportunism — it reflects a genuine market signal. Cash-pay weight management and hormone therapy allow NPs to generate revenue immediately while the slow insurance credentialing process grinds forward. As one family NP considering direct primary care told us, "I already have patients who tell me as soon as I start my own practice, they'd be the first in line." Primary care becomes the clinical foundation; high-margin wellness services become the financial engine that makes the practice viable.

27% are rejecting the insurance model entirely

More than a quarter of NPs we spoke with expressed interest in cash-pay or direct primary care models — practices that bypass insurance altogether. Combined with the GLP-1 and hormone therapy pivot, this signals a structural shift: NPs aren't just building practices differently, they're building them on a fundamentally different business model. Cash-pay eliminates the credentialing bottleneck, accelerates time to first patient, and gives NPs direct financial relationships with the people they serve.

27%

interested in cash-pay or direct primary care

NPs aren't building single-service practices — they're building revenue stacks

Primary care + Telehealth
70
Telehealth + Wellness
31
Telehealth + Weight loss
28
Primary care + Wellness
28
Primary care + Weight loss
22
Hormones + Primary care
19

The implication for anyone supporting NP practice launches: the product isn't a "primary care practice launch." It's a multi-service, hybrid-delivery practice launch — fundamentally more complex, but also more financially resilient.

WHAT'S STOPPING THEM

Two-thirds have started. Most didn't finish.

This statistic — that two-thirds of NPs we spoke with had already taken concrete steps toward practice ownership — might sound encouraging. But it masks a harder truth. Having an LLC doesn't mean you have patients. Having an EIN doesn't mean you've navigated credentialing. Most of these NPs are somewhere in the long, confusing middle of a process they don't fully understand. As one NP told us, "I know absolutely nothing of the business aspect, so just trying to do my own research has been difficult."

The barriers they face are structural, not personal. NP education programs include zero mandated business or practice management training (AACN, 2022). A nurse practitioner can complete a doctoral program without ever learning how to read a P&L statement, file for an NPI, or negotiate a payer contract. When they attempt to go independent, they encounter a credentialing system that varies by state, a Medicare reimbursement penalty that pays them 85 cents on the physician dollar (CMS, 2024), and a fragmented ecosystem of tools — each solving one piece of the puzzle, none solving the whole thing.

66%

already formed an LLC, obtained an EIN, or started credentialing

These aren't people at the idea stage. They started and got stuck.

Audited via random sample: 83% true positive rate. Selection bias: NPs seeking help are further along than the general population.
01

Zero business training in NP education

AACN, 2022

85¢

85 cents on the dollar

NPs billed independently get 85% of Medicare physician rate — unchanged since 1997

CMS / Balanced Budget Act, 1997

#1

Credentialing: the universal bottleneck

#1 topic across all conversations

Primary research

50

50 different state regulatory systems

For a workforce that wants hybrid telehealth + in-person

AANP, 2025

"The fear of failure and not being successful... the uncertainties and the unknown of where to even start."
— NP with 15 years experience, 25 years in nursing

These are highly trained clinicians doing exactly what they were trained to do — provide patient care. What they were never trained to do is run a business.

The system doesn't fail them at the clinical level. It fails them at every other level — business formation, credentialing, billing, marketing, compliance. The 66% who have already started are proof that motivation isn't the problem. Infrastructure is.

WHAT NEEDS TO CHANGE

Four things that would unlock 157,000 potential practices

The primary care crisis will not be solved by training more physicians. The pipeline is too slow, the economics too unfavorable, and the competition from specialty medicine too strong. But there are 461,000 nurse practitioners already in the workforce (AANP, 2025) — trained, licensed, and increasingly looking for a way out of a system that is burning them out.

The path from employed NP to independent practice owner is navigable. The 160 NPs we spoke with prove that the demand exists, the clinical capability is there, and the patient need is urgent. What's missing is the infrastructure to make the journey possible at scale. Four changes would unlock it.

1

Business training in NP education

13-year veterans say "I know absolutely nothing about business"

2

Medicare billing parity

Same work, same training — 85 cents on the dollar

3

Multi-state credentialing reform

50 different state regulatory systems for a workforce where 54% want hybrid

4

End-to-end practice launch infrastructure

Credentialing, EHR, marketing, compliance — nobody owns the whole journey

Independent practices have declined from 60.1% to 42.2% in just twelve years (AMA Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 2024). If that trend continues, the model of community-based, provider-owned care will effectively disappear within a generation — replaced entirely by corporate systems optimized for volume, not outcomes.

Nurse practitioners are the one workforce large enough, growing fast enough, and trained well enough to reverse that trend. But not if the barriers remain.

METHODOLOGY

About this research

  • 160 substantive conversations (5+ minutes)
  • 36 states, November 2024 – December 2025
  • All conversations were initial consultations with Practice with Joy
  • Analysis: qualitative coding, semantic search, and manual verification

Caveats

  • Selection bias: NPs actively seeking practice launch support are further along than the general population
  • Experience level classified for 51% of contacts
  • Trigger analysis based on 24% subset with identifiable triggers
  • Quotes anonymized; attributions based on specialty and experience
  • This report captures intent, not outcomes — we don't track who actually launched

Sources

  1. HRSA HPSA Quarterly Report, 2025
  2. Commonwealth Fund, "The State of Rural Primary Care," 2025
  3. AAMC, "Physician Workforce Projections," 2024
  4. Milbank Memorial Fund, "Health of US Primary Care Scorecard," 2024
  5. AANP National NP Database, 2025
  6. AMA Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 2024
  7. Nurse.org State of Nursing Survey, 2024
  8. Nursing Outlook, "NP Turnover Study," 2024
  9. Bain & Company, "Frontline of Healthcare," 2022
  10. Single Aim Health, "NP Entrepreneurship Report," 2024
  11. Practice with Joy primary research, 2024–2025